Medium is the Message   5 comments

Nothing about a cop on my doorstep says “I care about you.”


An Unfortunate Family Incident

We had an unfortunate incident here at our home this weekend. A relative was angered that my father-in-law, who is living with us, had blocked her phone number so she immediately jumped to the conclusion that he was in danger and called the police to conduct a welfare check. I won’t go into all the family dynamics of why this was incredibly inappropriate behavior, but suffice it to say this resulted in two armed police officers coming to our door to talk to my father-in-law who is now very irritated at his stepdaughter. Meanwhile, who knows what our neighbors are thinking. The ones who don’t know us probably now think we’re up to no good when in reality we are accepting responsibility our accuser shirked. Good going, step-sis. I love you too and I’m so feeling the love.

The Larger World

Sometimes these welfare checks culminate in death.

In Hawaii, armed police officers tried to perform a welfare check on a supposedly mentally ill man, who opened fire on them before setting fire to the apartment complex, resulting in several deaths. Having worked in the mental health field for over a decade, I can’t help but wonder if that could have been avoided.

There have been several incidents of cops shooting the homeowner while supposedly checking up on their safety. This is just one example. In others, the welfare check triggered a violent reaction no doubt born of fear that cops were going to arrest or even kill the person being “checked” on. Yes, in many cases the death can be blamed on the reaction of the citizen, but let’s consider that they weren’t hurting anyone until the point where armed officers showed up on their doorstep engaging in intimidating and aggressive behavior. Maybe the ultimate blame lies with the fact that there were cops at their door to begin with.

A friend tells me he recently had cops on his doorstep not long after telling a neighbor to not allow her dog to take a dump on his lawn. You don’t get much more passive-aggressive than that. He rightfully told her to stop violating his property rights and she called the cops on him rather than admit to herself that she was wrong in the first place.

While our interaction with the cops turned out okay, my husband had the distinct impression the officers tried to escalate the situation through the use of body language that was subtly, and at turns, overtly intimidating. I think he has a point. If I didn’t have 15 years in the mental health field, things might have turned out differently and certainly, that appears to have been the hope of my husband’s stepsister who sought to use the police as a proxy for her aggression.

Considerations

We want our elderly and vulnerable citizens to be taken care of, but is calling for men and women with guns to invade their personal space the way to do that? What is the message we’re sending? Is the message being received as care and love or intimidation and oppression? And are we not setting up future stress and possible violent response because now the person being “checked” on feels harassed and in fear of their freedom and safety?

Just pause and think about this. Why are we calling the cops on our neighbors in order to find out if they’re okay and not hurting themselves? Why don’t we care enough about our neighbors and relatives to do the welfare check ourselves? After all, I know my neighbor of 16 years far better than a cop with two minutes of acquaintance does and I am manifestly less intimidating. Are police even qualified to determine if a person is fine? And, are we sometimes simply using the police as a proxy for our own aggression?

Cops are Hammers

Police are trained to arrest people — to use force and intimidation to elicit responses from citizens in order to fine them or put them in jail. That is the #1 job of a police officer and it is the primary focus of their police academy training. Most receive very little training in mental health assessment and less training in constitutional rights or non-violent conflict resolution. They exist to be the first-responder to a crime and so the cops at my door last night assumed there was a crime in progress. They weren’t there to determine if my father-in-law was okay, but to determine if my husband and I were guilty of the allegations made by an out-of-state relative. Cops are hammers and to them, everything looks like a nail. If they’re at your door, they’re looking for evidence of a crime. That’s not friendly or loving.

Viewed that way, does it make sense to send them — fully armed and wearing tactical gear — to investigate whether someone who is vulnerable or mentally-ill is okay? Does that feel loving? Caring? Is that likely to cause fear and set off a response that isn’t loving or caring?

Medium Is the Message

Marshall McLuhan wrote “The medium is the message.” How we say something is as important as what we say — possibly more important.

Nothing about a cop on my doorstep feels like the person who sent them wants my good health and happiness. I’m an ordinary adult with an advanced degree who has never been arrested, but last night I felt attacked, oppressed and intimidated … like I might be arrested for making sure that an old man gets fed, kept warm and has interaction with people who care about him.

Pause and Rethink

This country needs to rethink a whole lot of things that have developed without deep consideration. Without paying attention, we’ve become a fairly totalitarian state in many of our interactions with our fellow citizens. How we check on the welfare of vulnerable people is among those things. We consider almost everything in our lives to be someone else’s responsibility — including the welfare of our elderly relatives and neighbors. We don’t go and talk to our neighbors anymore. We harass our relatives over the phone and then expect them to comply with our wishes. We call the cops rather than take a deep breath and consider what we might be doing to alienate the other person. But more than this — we call the cops to do what they are not trained or tasked to do.

Social workers are more appropriate to the task of welfare checks. They are unarmed, dressed in plain clothes and therefore are a lot less intimidating — not to mention they don’t send the wrong message to the neighbors. They lack the authority to arrest anyone and — bonus, they are actually trained in assessment of health conditions that should be a concern.

A lot of the violence in society stems from people feeling violated and, yes, cops on our doorstep are a violation of the dignity of the individual. We need to consider the messages we are sending and most especially how the medium we choose to use distorts our messages. Maybe we do care about our relative’s safety, but armed cops on their doorstep says, “We’ve come to restrict your freedom and put you in a box until you comply with our demands”. That’s not a loving message.

Nothing about a cop on my doorstep says you love and care about me, so hey, if you want me to feel loved, don’t send a cop.

Posted January 23, 2020 by aurorawatcherak in Uncategorized

5 responses to “Medium is the Message

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I have observed 2 situations in which a situation involving a cop was initiated. In both cases the cop took the lead and escalated the situation. Both situations thankfully did not end in violence.
    I missed the opportunity to experience a cop at the front door my wife was home to receive a summons for me to appear in court. No crime on my part. I was being called as a witness. It initially gave my wife a scare when the officer first appeared.

    Like

    • Yeah, my husband’s sister is acting like an ass because now that their father is living with us, she “cares” about his status — and she believes her brother, my husband, is dangerous for ancient history I won’t go into.

      Two cops walked up on him on our frontage, as he was getting the mail. They started him, pulling up on a side road and coming out of the darkness. The female of the two said “We’re here to check on the welfare of (shall remain anonymous).” And, then she stepped into my husband’s personal space — that area defined by how far you can reach your arm out. He stepped back into our driveway, into undisputed personal property and told them everything was fine and that they should go away now. Since they didn’t have a warrant, they can’t enter the property at that point. I called the sargeant and straightened it out over the phone and then we all had to attend an interview yesterday, but — yeah — there’s nothing about a cop on our doorstep that says you love us or even love your dad.

      Like

      • If the in-laws motivation is actually about his personal welfare she would have gone about it very differently. He medium is clearly also the message. Sad that we treat each other in less than helpful ways. Glad you had the skills to de-escalate what could have gone very differently.

        Like

      • My husband contemplated whether to cal l the police on her since she has his dad’s vehicle at her house, but then he decided it was just escalating the situation and just informed her that we’re dropping the insurance to storage insurance, so she’ll need to pay for liability insurance if she plans to drive it. He’s hoping she’ll learn from that. I doubt she will.

        Like

      • It’s sad but some people have their blind spot and no one can convince them otherwise.

        Like

What's Your Opinion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Inside My Mind

Words from my brain

Happiness Between Tails by da-AL

Tales of Writing + Books + Compassion + Culture + Wagging Tails

Fairfax and Glew

Vigilante Justice

The Wolf's Den

Overthink Everything

SaltandNovels

Sprinkling wonder into writing

Remmington Reads

A book enthusiast bringing you all things bookish

MiddleMe

Becoming Unstuck

Magical BookLush

A New Dimension to Explore!! Love for books and series is all we need. Life can be lonely without books. All I love is books, series, and talking about serious causes like bodyshaming. Do join me if you love to live your life to the fullest

Jacquie Biggar-USA Today Best-selling author

Read. Write. Love. 💕💕💕

Not Very Deep Thoughts

Short Fiction and Other Things

Ediciones Promonet

Libros e eBooks educativos y de ficción

the dying fish

Book info, ordering, about me etc. in upper right

%d bloggers like this: