A Treatment for Authoritarianism   Leave a comment

Image result for image of george orwellAuthoritarians – whether they lean left or right – justify their politics by arguing for particular positions on issues they care about, often passionately. And, therein lies the problem. If you hold different values, you feel that you should be able to argue for your side. But if your goal is a free and civil society, then arguing an issue on its merits with an authoritarian usually means shooting yourself in the foot. They expect you to buy into the unstated assumption that underpins all authoritarian politics:

If X is right, then it’s okay, maybe even imperative, to force people to do X.

It may well be true that X is morally right and that society would be better if we all did it, but what makes it right to force others to do X even if it is morally right? Anti-authoritarians recognize this conundrum, but authoritarians on the left and right perceive a threat in the actions of “the other” that requires they respond with authority.

If we want to fight this strain from both sides of the political divide, we need to put the moral burden back on the authoritarians. Encourage them to answer some questions:

  • What punishment do you propose for any given transgression?
  • Can you justify the extent of the punishment?
  • What harm will be done by enforcement? Not just to the person being punished, but to society as a whole?
  • How do you know it wouldn’t be worth using non-coercive methods … education or persuasion … to move society in the preferred direction?
  • How exactly does my opinion or speech harm you?
  • Do human beings have the power of emotional control and, if they do, why don’t you exercise it?
  • If you don’t have control over your emotional responses, what makes you different from me in that respect? In other words, shouldn’t you care as much about hurting me by threatening my values as I should care about hurting you by threatening yours?
  • Why are your feelings more important than mine?

Abject tyranny is achieved when not only our freedom of action is constrained by power, but our freedom of speech, and therefore thought, is constrained too.

In Orwell’s dystopia, a collectivist authoritarian regime actually created words and forced people to speak them on pain of physical punishment. The purpose was to force people to interact with each other and perceive the world in a way that conformed to the wishes of the political leaders. Orwell, the socialist, who devoted his life to equality and eliminating privilege, recognized that a philosophy of equality that seeks to treat everyone fairly and kindly can’t deliver on that promise if it must be imposed by force on people whose honest feelings and views are ignored.



What's Your Opinion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Leo X. Robertson

News of my latest publications, events, and episodes of the Losing the Plot podcast!

Sherry Parnell

Author of "Let the Willows Weep"

Emerald Book Reviews

Book Reviews and Promotion Services

YA Chit Chat

The Ponderings of YA author J. Keller Ford

madchen863's Blog

Planet Earth: home of life


Radio for the Awake and Aware


Soweto isiPantsula Crew + Management


Just a redheaded woman who is obsessed with books

Mercedes Prunty Author

The Walking Mumbie

InsureZero Blog

All you need to know about Insurance

Creative Ideas for Starving Artists

Brain juice that revives and refreshes

Real Science

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts" - Richard Feynman

Marsha Ingrao

Traveling & Blogging Near and Far

Victoria (V.E.) Schwab

"You can't get a cup of tea big enough or a book long enough to suit me." ~C.S. Lewis

Darlene Foster's Blog

dreamer of dreams, teller of tales

All About Writing and more

Advice, challenges, poetry and prose

Tapestry ~ Treasures

My life is but a weaving between the Lord and me!

Sue Vincent's Daily Echo

Echoes of Life, Love and Laughter


Everything Historical And Much More...

%d bloggers like this: